Thursday, March 29, 2018

Captivity of the Oatman Girls - R B Stratton

In 1851, a family of west bound Mormon settlers were attacked by Indians in the desert of  the Mexican territory, about 80 miles from Fort Yuma, which was just across the Colorado River from present day Yuma, Arizona.  Most of the family was murdered, though the 15 year old son, Lorenzo, left for dead, survived, and two daughters, Ann, 8 and Olive, 14, were taken prisoners.  Ann died of starvation after a year in captivity and Olive was ransomed after four years, returning to society to re-join her brother.

This book is a re-publication of the third edition of the original text that was published in 1859.  The story was a sensationalizing of the attack and her captivity.  The often displayed image of a young woman with tattooed stripes along her chin is of Olive.  The writing is in the flowery, pious style of the mid-19th century.  There's little insight into the life of the tribe as Olive tells her story to the writer, the emphasis being on her survival and reunion. 

I found controversy in more modern accounts, some claiming she had children while in captivity, others denying that story.  Maybe some targeted DNA testing amongst the Yavapai and Mohave tribes would reveal something!

Published: 1857 (original)  Read: March 2018  Genre: historical biography

Theodore Roosevelt for Nature Lovers - ed. Mark Dawidziak

Sub-title: Adventures with America's Great Outdoorsman

A short book with snippets and stories about living and loving being in the outdoors from the twenty-sixth president. 

One of the things I love about genealogy his how it leads me to research the historical context of my ancestors' lives.  T.R. was born in 1859 and died in January of 1919.  He was a child during the Civil War, fought in the Spanish-American War and died shortly after the end of WWI.  For my family, he was a peer of my great-grandparents and a source of childhood stories for my grandparents.  They saw the cartoons of him portrayed as a lion or a bear in the newspapers and were the first generations to have Teddy bears.

I enjoyed reading this book for the background on his love of the outdoors that lead to him becoming an avid conservationists and while president, establishing some of the first national parks.  So much good reading in a small package!

Published: 2017   Read: March 2018  Genre: biography

Wednesday, March 7, 2018

Homo Deus - Yuval Noah Harari

Sub-title: A Brief History of Tomorrow

This was a heavy book, figuratively and literally!  Harari has a PhD in history and specializes in world history.  He wrote an earlier book on the history of mankind called Sapiens.  This book is a sort of sequel, describing the future of the human species.  He presents many provocative ideas based on the evolution of industry and technology in the modern age.  I was fascinated and fearful of some of his predictions.  Here are some quotes and snipets I wanted to keep:

Page 54 - "A baby was conceived using the mitochondrial DNA of a 3rd person so she has biologically three parents (this procedures was subsequently banned in the U.S.)"
Page 58 - "This is the paradox of historical knowledge.  Knowledge that does not change behaviour is useless.  But knowledge that changes behaviour quickly loses it relevance.  The more data we have and the better we understand history, the faster history alters its course and the faster our knowledge becomes outdated."
Page 132 - "...the crucial factor in our [humans] conquest of the world was our ability to connect many humans to one another."
Page - 143 - "All large-scale human cooperation is ultimately based on our belief in imagined orders.  These are set of rules that, despite existing only in our imagination, we believe to be a real and inviolable as gravity [examples, God].  As long as all Sapiens living in a particular locality believe in the sames stories, they all follow the same rules, making it easy to predict the behaviour of strangers and to organize mass-cooperation networks."

When he talks of "imagined orders" he's referring to a belief that is intersubjective - a belief that depends on communication among many humans, money being an example.  He posits that religious and nationalistic beliefs are also intersubjective and cease to exist if we cease to believe in them.

He goes on from this explanation of how the species acts based on commonly held beliefs to describe "The Modern Covenant" - an agreement we have made "to give up meaning in exchange for power".  Religion and nationalistic beliefs gave meaning to human life but restricted their power.  By letting go of a belief in a great cosmic plan life has no meaning.  "The modern world does not believe in purpose, only in cause.  If modernity has a motto, its 'shit happens'."  From this, he surmises, humans can do anything we want. "On the practical level modern life consists of a constant pursuit of power within a universe devoid meaning."

Page 304 - "If you want to make people believe in imaginary entities such as gods and nations, you should make them sacrifice something valuable".
Page 350 - "Most scientific research about the human mind and the human experience has been conducted on people from Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich and Democratic (WEIRD) societies.  The study of the human mind has so far assumed that Homo sapiens is Homer Simpson."
Page 366 - "Modern humanity is sick with FOMO - Fear of Missing Out and though we have more choice than ever before, we have lost the ability to really pay attention to whatever we choose."

He ends with three challenging questions:

  1. Are organisms really just algorithms, and is life really just data processing?
  2. What's more valuable intelligence or consciousness?
  3. What will happen to society, politics and daily life when non-conscious but highly intelligent algorithms know us better than we know ourselves?

Published: 2015   Read: March 2018  Genre: History, Science



Thursday, February 15, 2018

The Solace of Leaving Early - Haven Kimmel

I'd begun this review and never finished it, found it in my Draft folder.

This was the first book written by the author of a A Girl Named Zippy.  That book was a memoir of growing up in Ohio.

A young woman leaves school just before getting her PhD and returns to her home, unwilling to pursue life.  A local minister is beyond the interest level of his parishioners and is enlisted by her mother to bring her out of her funk.  Between them, they try to help two little girls who've lost their mother to a violent murder.  It's a strange combination and it took a while before the implausible story hooked me.
There's a lot of reflection on life and religion and family in this story that makes it well worth reading.


Published: 2002  Read: February 2018  Genre: Fiction