Sub-title: The Campaign Against Established Knowledge and Why it Matters.
This looked interesting at the time, with discussion of anti-intellectualism buzzing around. The author argues that while we have broader access to knowledge than any other time in history, it has resulted in declaring expertise without a depth of knowledge.
I was left with wondering if there was anything I could honestly consider myself an expert at.
Just recording some quotes:
p. 45 - the more specific reason that unskilled or incompetent people overestimate their abilities far more than others is because they lack a key skill called meta-cognition - the ability to know when you're not good at something by stepping back and realizing what your doing is wrong.
p. 77 Three-fourths of American undergraduate attend college that accept at least half of their applicants.
p 84 Students take correction as an insult; unearned praise and hollow success build a fragile arrogance.
p 112 Debunking does nothing
p 125 The distinction between lay people and professionals: volunteers do what interest them at any given time, while professionals employ their expertise every day. Professionals are people who can do their best work when they don't feel like it.
p 217 - Disdain for education is not merely "anti-rational"; it is almost reverse evolution away from tested knowledge and backward toward folk wisdom and myths passed by word of mouth.
p 218 Faced with a public that has no idea how most things work, experts likewise disengage, choosing to speak mostly to each other.
Published: 2017 Read: August 2017 Genre: non-fiction, sociology
Monday, May 14, 2018
Saturday, May 12, 2018
The Lost World of the Old Ones - David Roberts
Sub-title: Discoveries in the ancient southwest
I tried to get an earlier book by this author called In Search of the Old Ones that is a cult favorite among climbers and adventurers however its only available at the Heard Museum library for in-library use.
This sequel chronicles the explorations of the author throughout Arizona, Utah and New Mexico looking for remnants of ancient civilizations. He practises leaving artifacts as they are, instead of collecting and taking them away from where they were found. An amateur anthropologist and archeologist, he seeks out the experts to consult and travel with to understand the cultures.
A great read that gives me a new appreciation of the rich history of my part of the world.
Published: 2015 Read: May 2018 Genre: Adventure
I tried to get an earlier book by this author called In Search of the Old Ones that is a cult favorite among climbers and adventurers however its only available at the Heard Museum library for in-library use.
This sequel chronicles the explorations of the author throughout Arizona, Utah and New Mexico looking for remnants of ancient civilizations. He practises leaving artifacts as they are, instead of collecting and taking them away from where they were found. An amateur anthropologist and archeologist, he seeks out the experts to consult and travel with to understand the cultures.
A great read that gives me a new appreciation of the rich history of my part of the world.
Published: 2015 Read: May 2018 Genre: Adventure
Thursday, March 29, 2018
Captivity of the Oatman Girls - R B Stratton
In 1851, a family of west bound Mormon settlers were attacked by Indians in the desert of the Mexican territory, about 80 miles from Fort Yuma, which was just across the Colorado River from present day Yuma, Arizona. Most of the family was murdered, though the 15 year old son, Lorenzo, left for dead, survived, and two daughters, Ann, 8 and Olive, 14, were taken prisoners. Ann died of starvation after a year in captivity and Olive was ransomed after four years, returning to society to re-join her brother.
This book is a re-publication of the third edition of the original text that was published in 1859. The story was a sensationalizing of the attack and her captivity. The often displayed image of a young woman with tattooed stripes along her chin is of Olive. The writing is in the flowery, pious style of the mid-19th century. There's little insight into the life of the tribe as Olive tells her story to the writer, the emphasis being on her survival and reunion.
I found controversy in more modern accounts, some claiming she had children while in captivity, others denying that story. Maybe some targeted DNA testing amongst the Yavapai and Mohave tribes would reveal something!
Published: 1857 (original) Read: March 2018 Genre: historical biography
This book is a re-publication of the third edition of the original text that was published in 1859. The story was a sensationalizing of the attack and her captivity. The often displayed image of a young woman with tattooed stripes along her chin is of Olive. The writing is in the flowery, pious style of the mid-19th century. There's little insight into the life of the tribe as Olive tells her story to the writer, the emphasis being on her survival and reunion.
I found controversy in more modern accounts, some claiming she had children while in captivity, others denying that story. Maybe some targeted DNA testing amongst the Yavapai and Mohave tribes would reveal something!
Published: 1857 (original) Read: March 2018 Genre: historical biography
Theodore Roosevelt for Nature Lovers - ed. Mark Dawidziak
Sub-title: Adventures with America's Great Outdoorsman
A short book with snippets and stories about living and loving being in the outdoors from the twenty-sixth president.
One of the things I love about genealogy his how it leads me to research the historical context of my ancestors' lives. T.R. was born in 1859 and died in January of 1919. He was a child during the Civil War, fought in the Spanish-American War and died shortly after the end of WWI. For my family, he was a peer of my great-grandparents and a source of childhood stories for my grandparents. They saw the cartoons of him portrayed as a lion or a bear in the newspapers and were the first generations to have Teddy bears.
I enjoyed reading this book for the background on his love of the outdoors that lead to him becoming an avid conservationists and while president, establishing some of the first national parks. So much good reading in a small package!
Published: 2017 Read: March 2018 Genre: biography
A short book with snippets and stories about living and loving being in the outdoors from the twenty-sixth president.
One of the things I love about genealogy his how it leads me to research the historical context of my ancestors' lives. T.R. was born in 1859 and died in January of 1919. He was a child during the Civil War, fought in the Spanish-American War and died shortly after the end of WWI. For my family, he was a peer of my great-grandparents and a source of childhood stories for my grandparents. They saw the cartoons of him portrayed as a lion or a bear in the newspapers and were the first generations to have Teddy bears.
I enjoyed reading this book for the background on his love of the outdoors that lead to him becoming an avid conservationists and while president, establishing some of the first national parks. So much good reading in a small package!
Published: 2017 Read: March 2018 Genre: biography
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)