Wednesday, April 28, 2021

White Fragility - Robin Diangelo

Sub-title: Why It's So Hard for White People to Talk about Racism

In the current political and social environment, this book was recommended to me by a relative who had read it for a diversity program.  This was a difficult read as it provided a viewpoint I don't think I'd been exposed to in the past and challenged my thinking on the topic of race.  

The author explains the evolution of white privilege in our society and its consequences and why it is so difficult to see ourselves as racist as a result of being born and raised in it.  I have a long way to go.

Quotes:

"The idea of racial inferiority was created to justify unequal treatment; belief in racial inferiority is not what triggered unequal treatment...first, we exploited people for their resources, not according to how they looked."

"Narratives of racial exceptionality [example of Jackie Robinson first African American in major league baseball] obscure the reality on ongoing institutional white control while reinforcing the ideologies of individualism and meritocracy." 

[Color blind - insists they don't see race, Color celebrate - sees and embraces diversity] "All the statements [made by these groups of people] ultimately function in a similar way; they all exempt the person from any responsibility for or participation in the problem." 

[Difference between race prejudice /discrimination and racism] While everyone of every race holds prejudice and can discriminate against someone of another race, in the US and other white/settler nations, only white people are in the position to oppress people of color collectively and throughout the whole of society."

"Conceptualizing myself on an active continuum changes the question from whether I am or am not racist to a much more constructive question: Am I actively seeking to interrupt racism in this context?  And perhaps even more importantly, how do I know?" 

"White fragility is also evidenced in the need for so many white progressives to 'build trust' before they can explore racism..[they are saying].I need to trust that you won't think I am racist before I can work on my racism." 

"To let go of the messenger and focus on the message is an advanced skill...Part of processing of that feedback [on our racist behavior and thoughts] will be to separate it from its delivery and ascertain the central point and its contribution to my growth." 


Published:  2018  Read: April 2021  Genre: Sociology, Politics 

Rules for Visiting - Jessica Francis Kane

 The reviews on this one were good and I liked the concept - a woman reaches out to connect in person with her friends from the past in the age of instant communication.  It missed the mark.  The heroine, May, is strange; a detached, disconnected, landscape gardener.  The author interweaves descriptions of the personalities of various North American trees into the narrative to illustrate the choices of personalities we can adopt.  I think that what was she was trying to do.  The back story of May's life was so obscure that when it was revealed it was anticlimactic.  Some thoughtful observations kept me reading but in the end, the book fell flat

Quotes:

"Friends are God's apology for relations (Hugh Kingsmith)"

"...the Dunbar number--the maximum number of people with whom any individual can maintain stable relationships--and how, despite predictions, it hadn't gotten any bigger in the age of social media."

"A house is a physical thing that is build with wood and bricks, furnished with furniture and carpets, while a home takes time and is built with memories." 

"Perhaps a best friend is someone who...holds the story of your life in mind.  Sometimes in music a melodic line is so beautiful the notes feel inevitable; you can anticipate the next note through a long rest.  Maybe that is friendship.  A best friend holds your story in mind so notes don't have to be repeated." 

Published: 2019  Read: April 2020  Genre: Fiction 

 

Wednesday, April 14, 2021

A Well Behaved Woman - Therese Anne Fowler

 Sub-title: A novel of the Vanderbilt's

I read this for my church book club.  I enjoy reading about the lives of the rich and famous and the Vanderbilt family were one of the richest in the late 1800s when their patriarch, Cornelius "the Commodore" made his fortune in transportation, primarily railroads.  

This book is the story of Alva Smith, the wife of one of his grandsons, William Vanderbilt.  They married because she had old aristocratic lines from the South that extended to New York but her family money had run out.  Her husband and his family was nouveau riche and not accepted into New York society.  Alva bore three children; Consuelo, named after her best friend, William and Harold.  She ushered the Vanderbilt family into high society and divorced William when her best friend confessed to an affair with him of many years.  Alva then married Oscar Belmont and she later was involved in women's suffrage.

I found the story provided a different look at the "gilded age" and the time period.  

Published: 2018   Read: April 2021  Genre: historical fiction

Friday, April 9, 2021

The Vanishing Half - Brit Bennett

 Twin sisters choose different paths in life. Desiree and Stella are born into a "light-skinned" African American community.  Their father is lynched and murdered in front of them and when they reach adulthood, they strike out for New Orleans and a different life.  Stella discovers she can "pass" as white and deserts her sister to marry her boss at a marketing firm and lives with her blond, blue-eyed daughter in fear of being discovered.  Desiree marries an abusive man and leaves him to return to her hometown  where her very dark-skinned daughter faces prejudice.  This is a story of lives I've never thought about, much less experienced.  The story challenged my thinking about what stories I've read my whole life and the authors I've chosen and the perspectives I've been exposed to.  The writing is compelling.  It's a story like none I have ever read and yet like the best fiction I've read.  Highly recommended.

Quotes: 

"The hardest part about becoming someone else was deciding to.  The rest was only logistics."

"...her grandmother would not be sitting on the porch to greet them.  Her death hit in waves.  Not a flood, but water lapping at her ankles.  You could drown in two inches of water.  Maybe grief was the same." 

Published: 2020   Read: April 2021  Genre: Fiction