Wednesday, September 9, 2020

Before and After - Judy Christie and Lisa Wingate

 This is the book I wanted to be written when I read the fictionalized story of the Tennessee Children's Home Society.  It's the true stories of several of the children who were adopted through the Home run by an unscrupulous woman, Georgia Tann, who for over 30 years trafficked in children with impunity.

The first three-fourths of the book are positive, upbeat stories of how the children's lives turned out well despite always having a feeling of being different.  Most were raised as only children who were adopted into well-to-do homes.  The last few stories were not so positive.  The writing was weak and I was frustrated that the writers didn't seem to attempt to research adoption or unknown parentage. I also felt that their lack of organization in pulling the adoptees together was inexcusable, as if they were just trying to promote themselves and write a book and needed the stories to pull it together.  

Published: 2019  Read: September 2020   Genre: Non-fiction

I Will Be Complete - Glen David Gold

 

Back in 2018 I went to the Southern Festival of the Book in Nashville for the second time with my good friend, Kathryn.  It's a long weekend of many author's speaking about their books in multiple venues.  I'd started reading Glen David Gold's Carter Beats the Devil at one time but didn't finish it.  Listening to him tell the story of writing this memoir had me adding it to my TBR list and I finally got it from the library this month.

He had a tumultuous childhood, growing up in California with a flitty, flawed, bohemian mother and a boom to bust, cold father.  The book focuses on the disastrous relationship with his mother and his finally breaking away from her.

I felt that while their relationship was fraught with dysfunction, he was still a privileged, well-off, only child whose native intelligence did not extend to his emotional smarts.

Quotes:

"Recently a friend asked why it was so hard for me to understand that people are what they do.  It was a concept so slipper I needed to write it down and stare at it like an advanced algebraic equation."

"There isn't much that causes people to recoil more than sensing someone wants to be liked." 

"Regardless of the pride I took in the empty place in my chest, I still had a contrary faith I believed in so deeply that I'd mistaken it for an axiom.  If I love you hard enough I can fix you.  It doesn't work like that.  This is what I want to say so it's as familiar as the stars and sunrise: your love is not enough. 

 

Published: 2018  Read: September 2020  Genre: Memoir

Monday, August 31, 2020

I Think You're Wrong (But I'm Listening) - Sarah Stewart Holland & Beth Silvers

 Sub-title: a guide to grace-filled political conversations

With the divisive state of our country, this is a must-read book.  The authors have a podcast called "Pantsuit Politics" which they started in November 2015.  Their goal is to discuss and analyze political topics in a respectful, understanding way.  They provide an approach for having conversations with others who have different views from your own.  They emphasize the nuances and complexity of these discussions and advocate that we eliminate the "either/or" of our talks and strive to understand, empathize and dig deeper into the thoughts of others.  I encourage everyone to read it and consider their approach and try it out - it might make for a better world or at least a better family gathering!

Quotes:

p 68 [ask Why] "truly great leaders clearly identify, communicate, and act based on the reason their business or organization exists.  "Why" is always propelling "how" and "what".  For values or guiding principle to be truly effective they have to be verbs.  "it's not "integrity," it's "always do the right thing".  ...we can all tap into a personal value that can guide a more inquisitive, productive discussion about any political topic.

"We're all guilty of assuming that a step in a direction we don't embrace or understand will lead to extremes."

"Imagine the transformative impact of viewing our fellow citizens as though our big, messy country wouldn't be complete without them, as though we all belong here together, as though the challenge or working through a diversity of perspectives is an inherent, beautiful part of the American experience--of the human experience." 

"...we don't engage in dialogue or participate civically to change other people but rather to better understand them, ourselves, and the ideas we are discussing.  In political conversations, we have to meet people where they are and assume they'll stay there."

"Our brains might instinctually categorize in binary ways; however, our journey need not end there.  When we release ourselves from picking [a side] we also allow our brains to release their death grip on confirmation bias.  Embracing the paradox helps us realize that politics is not a collision of good and evil; it' a painstaking analysis of valid, competing priorities."

"Somewhere along the way, we decided as a country that we don't want to be uncomfortable at any time, for any reason. "

"We all grow through the discomfort of emotions like grief, rage, and sorrow, but first we have to allow ourselves to feel those emotions....There is only one good question: What are you unwilling to feel?"

"My constant refrain: You're free to speak.  You aren't free to speak without consequences."

"Social media platforms' technology is built on algorithms.  The problem social media platforms are trying to solve is how to gain and keep your attention...the system is built to please you, not to challenge you [or your thinking]".

In their chapter on "Exiting the Echo Chamber" they discuss an empathy map that helps you gain deeper insight into a point of view where you both intellectually understand someone else's feelings and vicariously experience those feelings.   We ask ourselves about the other person:

What do they think and feel? What really matters, major preoccupations, worries and aspirations?

What do they hear? what do friends say, what their boss says, what influencers say

What do the see? what is their environment, who are their friends, what does the market offer them?

What do they say or do? what is their attitude in public, appearances, behavior toward others?

What causes them pain, fear, frustration and what obstacles do they experience?

What do they want to gain, wants and needs, measures of success, obstacles to achieving?

In the final chapter they recommend taking the 5 commitments:

1) commit to recognizing and putting down your defensiveness

2) commit to learning something in a discussion

3) commit to having a dialogue instead of giving alternate speeches

4) commit to assessing whether you're the right person to say what is on your mind

5) commit to ending the discussion knowing that you have strengthened the relationship.

Published:  2019  Read: August 2020  Genre: Politics

Thursday, August 27, 2020

The Magicians - Lev Goldman

 In this strange time, the library is doing car seat delivery and when I pick up the books I chose they offer "bonus" books.  This was one of those bonus books and it was delightful.  It weaves in a Harry Potter-like special school for children with "magic" talent with a twist.  The young people graduate and find that their lives are still a challenge for those who are different.  A clever story and an interesting read.

Published: 2009   Read: September 2020  Genre: Fiction