Thursday, July 22, 2021

Deep Ancestry - Spencer Wells

 Sub-title: Inside the Genographic Project - The Landmark DNA Quest to Decipher Our Distant Past

Over the summer, the Southern Arizona Genealogical Society had a book sale at their site in Green Valley.  A friend and I took a day trip to explore their offerings and came home with many future reads, this title being one of them.

 The National Genographic Project was a research project initiated in 2005 to document the paths of human migration over time, using YDNA and mitochondrial DNA.  The project gathered DNA samples from many indigenous people around the world as well as offering DNA tests for sale to partially fund its efforts; some of you may have participated in the project.  The project was closed in 2020 and test results are no longer available to testers. 

 The focus of the research was to expand the data used to conduct anthropological investigations of human migration.  In the book, Wells describes the migration path of homo sapiens out of Africa and across the globe.  I was fascinated with how the YDNA and mtDNA haplogroups evolved over tens of thousands of years.  This book expanded my knowledge of haplogroup studies.  The last chapters takes the reader through the evolution of both lineages and makes a good resource for understanding the sometimes confusing jumble of haplogroup names.  

Quotes:

"In August of 2002 I had recently finished a film and a book, The Journey of Man."

"Members of the Q [haplogroup] lineage share the genetic marker M242 with the people living in Siberia...When they arrived in North America, they were the first humans ever to inhabit this continent."

"This disconnect between the individual event and the sum of many events is a result of a statistical property known as the law of large numbers.  The error introduced by using a small number of events is known as sampling error.  What does all of this have to do with genetic lineages?  The likelihood of passing on one's genes varies from person to person, but if we have a large number of people, then it tends to even out in such a way that the variation distinguishing the population is transmitted to the next generation in the same proportions seen today.  The change in frequency from generation to generation due to sampling error is known as genetic drift."

"..we still know very little about the underlying genetic changes that determine human appearance.  As these genetic markers are discovered...we should be able to test the theory that humans diverged in their surface features due to sexual selection.  Exploring this idea is one of the goals of the Genographic Project."

"...results were finally confirmed in a study published in 2000 that narrowed the estimated date [of mitochondrial Eve] to around 170,000 years, mitochondrial Eve was African."

"In a paper published in 2000...it showed our common Y-chr ancestor lived only 60,000 years ago.  [Because of] variance in reproductive success, is higher for men than women, which means that women have more equal opportunities to have children...tends to reduce the effective population size of the Y chr.  Over time, this meant that Y lineages were more likely to be lost than mtDNA lineages.  The result is that the deeper Y lineages were lost over the past 170,000 years, and the only ones left date to around 60,000 years ago.


Published: 2006  Read: July 2021  Genre: Science


Wednesday, June 30, 2021

Not My Father's Son - Alan Cumming

 Recommended by a fellow genealogist, this was a quick and heart-breaking read.  Alan is a well known and lauded actor.  His childhood was laced with violence from his father, a miserable, unhappy man who took his anger out on his children...or were they "his"?  

A DNA test seems to resolve the question though it raised further speculation in my mind.  I won't give away the story but recommend reading.  The book is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit.

Published: 2014  Read: 2021 Genre: Memoir

Monday, June 28, 2021

21 Lessons for the 21st Century - Yuval Noah Harari

 I looked forward to reading this book as I had read and enjoyed the author's other book Homo Deus that I read back in 2015.  Once again he poses challenging and thought-provoking ideas, this time around looking toward the future of humankind.  I marked quite a few passages. While raising the flags of warning for the future, his personal prescription of meditation as a means of dealing with it felt flat with me.  Still, I recommend reading for its wide range of observations.

"Big Data algorithms might create digital dictatorships in which all power is concentrated in the hands of a tiny elite while most people suffer not from exploitation but from something far worse--irrelevance."

[Regarding Artificial Intelligence or AI] "AI is now beginning to outperform humans in more and more of these [physical and cognitive] skills, including in the understanding of human emotions.  We don't know of any third field of activity--beyond the physical and the cognitive--where humans will always retain a secure edge."

"This reliance on the heart [as a guide for action] might prove to be the Achilles' heel of liberal democracy.  For once somebody gains the technological ability to hack and manipulate the human heart, democratic politics will mutate into an emotional puppet show."

"If we want to prevent the concentration of all wealth and power in the hands of a small elite, the key is to regulate the ownership of data."

"The nationalist wave sweeping across the world cannot return the world to 1939 or 1914.  Technology has changed everything by creating a set of global existential threats that no nation can solve on its own.  A common enemy is the best catalyst for forging a common identity, and humankind now has at least three such enemies - nuclear war, climate change, and technological disruption."

"You cannot experience joy and harmony when you are boiling with anger or envy.  Long before you murder anyone, your anger has already killed your own peace of mind."

[The secular ethical code] which is in fact accepted by millions of Muslims, Christians, and Hindus as well as by atheists--enshrines the values of truth, compassion, equality, freedom, courage, and responsibility.  It forms the foundation of modern scientific and democratic institutions."

"We think we know a lot, even though individually we know very little, because we treat knowledge in the minds of others as if it were our own."

[Aldous Huxley's] genius consists in showing that you can control people far more securely thorough love and pleasure than through fear and violence."

"Many pedagogical experts argue that schools should switch to teaching 'the four Cs'-- critical thinking, communication, collaboration, and creativity."

"In front of the amazed eyes of the assembled peasants the priest held high a piece of bread and exclaimed 'Hoc est corpus!'-- ' This is the body!'-- In the minds of the illiterate peasants, who did not speak Latin, 'Hoc est corpus!' got garbled into 'Hocus-pocus!'. Thus was born the powerful spell that can transform a frog into a prince and a pumpkin into a carriage."

"If by 'free will' you mean the freedom to do what you desire, then yes, humans have free will.  But if by 'free will' you mean the freedom to chose what to desire, then no, humans have no free will."

"When you are confronted by some great story and you wish to know whether it is real or imaginary, one of the key questions to ask is whether the central hero of the story can suffer."

Published: August 2018   Read: June 2021  Genre: History, Politics

Friday, June 25, 2021

American Baby - Gabrielle Glaser

 Sub-title: A Mother, A Child, and the Shadow History of Adoption

I read this book in one day, it was riveting, to say the least.  Framed by the story of one birth mother forced to give up her son at birth, it tells of the thousands of females in the 1950s, 60s and 70s who were shuttled off in shame to homes where they gave birth to their illegitimate children and were forced to give them up for adoption into a system riddled with greed, dishonesty and self-righteous patter.  For me it explained why there are so many people testing their DNA to find their birth parents or child.  

Quotes

"...music of which their parents disapproved: Elvis Presley, Chubby Checker...--music that Alan Freed, the DJ...had introduced as "rock 'n' roll" - African American slang for sex----"

"Viola Bernard, a Columbia University psychiatrist...and Peter Neubauer, a New York University psychiatrist who was a protege of Anna Freud's...study of nature over nurture...caused separation of twins and triplets at birth.  The records for the Bernard/Neubauer study are sealed until 2065..." 

"By adding birth and adoptive parents, plus siblings, half siblings, and eight grandparents, she said, adoptee-rights advocates estimated that approximately a third of American had a link to adoption in their direct immediate families."


Published: 2021  Read: June 2021  Genre: Non-fiction, genealogy