Tuesday, November 29, 2022

Democracy's Data - Dan Bouk

 Sub-title: The Hidden Stories in the U.S. Census and How to Read Them

The author, a computational mathematician and historian, takes us on a journey through the evolution of the U.S. census, using the 1940 census that was released in 2012.  He takes us through how the census questions were chosen, how the forms were distributed and tallied, how the enumerators interviewed the people and how the population responded.  A geeky, nerdy read for a genealogist that adds a perspective on what went in to creating one of our valuable sources.  Did you know the 1850 census missed a huge part of California due to a fire?  Or that in 1920, Tacoma Washington's rolls were overstated by 30,000 imaginary people?

Bouk tells the stories behind the data, beginning with "the Question Men', the government officials (all men, except for one woman) who chose the questions to be included, and which ones to exclude.  He covers the doorstep negotiations on what name was recorded by the enumerator and the force fitting of everyone into a form designed for a traditional nuclear family.  He demonstrates how what and who was left out of the census reflected the values, good and bad, of the 1940s and the decades before then.  It devotes a chapter to how a politician encouraged the population to not answer the census as he framed it as a a breach of privacy and it's use to identify Japanese Americans in WWII was an egregious abuse. 

I enjoyed learning the history of the census, its benefits and shortcomings and most of all its importance to our country.  

Quotes:

"The historian of quantification Caitlin Rosenthal teaches students to read the frame of the data- the column headings and row names whatever organizes and constrains the data."

"In 1850, the census began enumerating each free individual by  name.  ..Ralph Waldo Emerson called this time the age of the first person singular."

"Jennifer Mendelsohn's...#resistancegenealogy"

"The 1920 census was plagued by padding fiascos- most spectacularly in Tacoma, Washington...conspired with local enumerators to make up more than thirty thousand people."

"maps created by...risk evaluators for the Home Owners' Loan Corporation (HOLC) to support federal mortgage lending."

"The Census Bureau lent its experts to the INS to help design the alien-registration forms, to facilitate the nationwide process of getting immigrants to register..."

"In 1850, the official report noted that the new state of California had suffered a data catastrophe, with multiple counties' worth of figures (including San Francisco County) were burned or lost in transit."

"Big data ...innovator says don't worry about where the data came from...this book has made clear how foolish and dangerous a cry like that is.   When data ets represent people, those who want to ue that data should have to think..how those datafied persons can continue to be faithfully and justly represented."

"In 1929 the number of representatives was capped at 435 and the number of people represented was 40,000 ...and has risen to 700,000."

Published: 2022  Read: November 2022  Genre: History


Monday, November 14, 2022

The Smartest Guys in the Room: - Bethany McLean, Peter Elkind

 Sub-title: The Amazing Rise and Scandalous Fall of Enron 

I'd taken a while to finish this, reading a bit at night for several weeks.  It's a hard story to take.  The greed, arrogance, bravado of smart people without a conscience or concern what whether what they were doing was right, only that it could be done.  

Published: 2013  Read: November 2022  Genre: Business, History


Sunday, October 30, 2022

Credentials for Genealogists - Paul Gorry

 Sub-title: Proof of the Professional

Sometimes, you read something to expand your knowledge of a teeny slice of a subject and add to your understanding of a niche topic.  I ordered this book off of Amazon to see the full picture of what educational opportunities exist for those of us interested in genealogy to have "credentials" to prove our knowledge and experience. This is a fantastic summary of the different programs and organizations.  It provides a history of their development and where they are today.  There's a list of the acronyms representing the various offerings, a good reference for any genealogist.  I recommend it for your genealogy reference shelf.


Published: 2021 (2nd Ed) Read: October 2022  Genre: Science

Monday, October 24, 2022

American Nations - Colin Woodard

Sub-title: A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America

Do you have ancestors from the 17th and 18th centuries in North America? Are you tracing families as they migrated across the United States?  Woodard takes us through the wave of settlers in North America and illustrates the impact of their differing beliefs and values on our society today.  I recommend this book as a must read for any genealogist!

The book asks "Why do Americans have such a difficult time agreeing on basic issues?"  The answer is that the different regions of the country evolved from eleven different "nations".  For genealogists, his description of their settling and migrating across the United States provides essential insight into the origins of our ancestors.

The 11 regions described are: El Norte, New France, Tidewater, Yankeedom, New Netherland, Deep South, Midlands, Greater Appalachia, Far West, the Left Coast, and First Nation. Each region grew from their founding members into distinct groups with shared goals reflected in their viewpoints.

El Norte originated with the Spanish explorers and settled New Mexico, Texas, Arizona.  New France settled North East Canada and Louisiana. Tidewater originated with English settlers to Virginia. the Pilgrims and Puritans desired to build new societies in Yankeedom. New Netherland originated with the Dutch settlers in New York.  

The Deep South grew from entrepreneurs from the Caribbean exploiting slave labor..the Midlands from those moving away from the East Coast regions...Greater Appalachia from Scotch/Irish wanting to be left alone.  The Far West ...Left Coast and First Nation grew from the migration of the first groups across the continent.  The author goes into detail on each regions' founding and it evolution to date.

Interestingly, in the Epilogue, he addresses what the future of these regions that now form the United States. He predicted in 2011 when the book was published the possibility that 

"faced with a major crisis, the federations leaders will betray their oath to uphold the U.S. Constitution... In the midst of say, a deadly pandemic outbreak...a fearful public might condone the suspension of civil rights. One can easily imagine circumstances in which some nations are happy with the new order and others deeply opposed to it."

A great read with a fascinating perspective on how we all got here. 

Quotes:

"Cultural geographers came to similar conclusions decades ago.  ...formulating a key theory...called the Doctrine of First Effective Settlement" 

p. 317 "the red and blue nations will continue to wrestle with one another for control over federal policy...just as they have since the First Continental Congress."  

MAP of nations


 

Published: 2011  Read: September 2022